Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co Menu

Welcome to Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co, a slice of Brooklyn nestled in Scottsdale, AZ. This pizza haven boasts a menu that captures the essence of authentic New York-style pizza, with a variety of offerings that are sure to satisfy any craving. From their all-day favorites such as Old School Garlic Knots and Totally Cheesy Knots to hearty Calzones and Stromboli, each dish is crafted with fresh ingredients and a passion for flavor.

Pizza lovers will revel in the large, mouth-watering slices that echo the bustling streets of NYC. Customers rave about the crispy crust and perfectly melted cheese. Popular picks include the City Slickers Calzone and Bensonhurst Baked Ziti, showcasing the restaurant’s diverse culinary range. Yo Pauly's isn't just about food; it's about creating an inviting experience that brings people together. Don't miss out on their renowned service, making every visit memorable!

All Day - Somethin' to Munch On

• Old School Garlic Knots

  US$4.20

• Totally Cheesy Knots

  US$5.99

• Manhattan Meatballs

  US$7.19

• Fried Rav's (6)

  US$7.19

• Fried Rav's (12)

  US$14.39

• French Fries (Basket)

  US$5.40

• Mozzarella Sticks (6)

  US$8.39

• Mozzarella Sticks (12)

  US$15.59

All Day - Big City Salads

• Small Standard Antipasto

  US$8.39

• Large Standard Antipasto

  US$15.59

• Small Jimmy The Greek

  US$8.39

• Large Jimmy The Greek

  US$15.59

• Small Chop Salad

  US$8.39

• Large Chop Salad

  US$15.59

• Small Traditional House

  US$6.59

• Large Traditional House

  US$11.99

• Small Hail Caesar

  US$6.59

• Large Hail Caesar

  US$11.39

All Day - Get-Cha Wings!

• Single Hit (12)

  US$16.19

All Day - Yo Pauly's Piz'zas

• 10" Cheese Louise

  US$11.99

• 14" Cheese Louise

  US$17.40

• 18" Cheese Louise

  US$22.80

• 10" Da Midtown Meltdown

  US$16.20

• 14" Da Midtown Meltdown

  US$22.20

• 18" Da Midtown Meltdown

  US$29.99

• 10" Margarita Village

  US$14.39

• 14" Margarita Village

  US$21.59

• 18" Margarita Village

  US$28.79

• 10" It's All Greek To Me

  US$16.20

• 14" It's All Greek To Me

  US$23.40

• 18" It's All Greek To Me

  US$30.60

• 10" Hawaiian Vacation

  US$16.20

• 14" Hawaiian Vacation

  US$23.40

• 18" Hawaiian Vacation

  US$30.60

• 10" The Godfather

  US$16.20

• 14" The Godfather

  US$23.40

• 18" The Godfather

  US$31.19

• 10" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken

  US$16.99

• 14" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken

  US$23.40

• 18" 5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken

  US$31.80

• 10" Whitestone Bridge

  US$16.99

• 14" Whitestone Bridge

  US$23.40

• 18" Whitestone Bridge

  US$30.60

• 10" Madison Square Garden

  US$16.20

• 14" Madison Square Garden

  US$23.40

• 18" Madison Square Garden

  US$29.40

• 10" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

  US$16.20

• 14" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

  US$23.40

• 18" Ziggy's Favorite ZA

  US$30.60

• 10" Wiseguy's Choice

  US$16.20

• 14" Wiseguy's Choice

  US$23.40

• 18" Wiseguy's Choice

  US$30.60

• 10" Melting Pot

  US$16.79

• 14" Melting Pot

  US$23.99

• 18" Melting Pot

  US$32.39

• 10" The Big Apple

  US$16.79

• 14" The Big Apple

  US$23.99

• 18" The Big Apple

  US$32.39

• 10" The New Yorker

  US$16.20

• 14" The New Yorker

  US$22.79

• 18" The New Yorker

  US$30.60

All Day - NY Calzones & Stromboli

• Ham It Up Calzone

  US$15.59

• Little Italy Calzone

  US$15.59

• Tri State Calzone

  US$15.59

• City Slickers Calzone

  US$15.59

• Daily News Stromboli

  US$15.59

All Day - Sandwiches

• The Mayor's Meatball Parmesan

  US$13.19

• Chelsea Chicken Parmesan

  US$14.39

• Goodfella's Eggplant Parmesan

  US$14.39

• Long Island BLT

  US$11.99

• The Italian Job

  US$13.19

• City Hall Chicken

  US$14.39

All Day - Sweet Endings

• NY Cheesecake

  US$6.90

• Coney Island Cannolis

  US$10.79

• 1 Cannoli

  US$2.40

All Day - Something to Drink

• Pepsi - Fountain

  US$3.30

• Diet Pepsi - Fountain

  US$3.30

• Starry - Fountain

  US$3.30

• Mtn Dew - Fountain

  US$3.30

• Brisk Iced Tea Unsweetened - Fountain

  US$3.30

• Brisk Iced Tea Raspberry - Fountain

  US$3.30

• Mug Root Beer - Fountain

  US$3.30

• Dr. Pepper - Fountain

  US$3.30

All Day - San Gennaro's Feast Dinner

• Sonny's Spaghetti

  US$14.39

• Bensonhurst Baked Ziti

  US$16.79

• Grandma's Chicken Parmesan

  US$17.99

• Mama Leone's Eggplant

  US$17.99

• Ravioli Rav's Dinner

  US$9.99

• Ravioli & Meatballs

  US$15.59

All Day - Yo Pauly's Kids Menu

• Arron's Pasta

  US$7.79

• Little Joey's Pizza

  US$6.59

• Eddie's Spaghetti & Meatball

  US$9.59

• Chicken Strips

  US$10.29